Carolyn Ambler brings deep local expertise to every transaction in the Florida Keys. Whether you're buying your first condo, selling a waterfront home, or investing in the Overseas Highway corridor — you get an agent who knows these islands inside out.
FL
Keys-native
Carolyn Ambler doesn't just sell properties in Islamorada — she understands the rhythm of island life. From the quiet charm of the Village to the vibrant energy along the Overseas Highway, every neighborhood has a story, and she knows how to tell yours.
With American Caribbean Real Estate, Carolyn brings a personal approach that big agencies can't replicate. Every client receives direct attention, honest counsel, and a strategy tailored to their goals — whether that's finding a forever home, timing a sale for maximum return, or identifying a sound investment in one of the most desirable coastal markets in the country.
100%
Client-focused approach
Deep
Local market knowledge
From first-time buyers to seasoned investors, every service is delivered with the same standard of care and local expertise.
Whether you're searching for a waterfront retreat, a cozy condo, or an investment property, Carolyn guides you through every step — from listing to closing.
Strategic pricing, professional presentation, and expert negotiation — designed to get you the best possible outcome in today's Keys market.
The Florida Keys offer unique opportunities for investors. Get informed counsel on rental potential, appreciation trends, and market timing.
From canal-front homes to direct Gulf access estates, waterfront living in the Keys is a lifestyle. Let Carolyn help you find the right one.
Islamorada offers a range of condo and townhome options. Carolyn understands HOA structures, rental restrictions, and what matters most to buyers.
Not ready to list or buy? Start with a conversation. Carolyn offers no-pressure consultations to help you understand your options in the Keys market.
A curated selection of current listings across Islamorada's most sought-after neighborhoods.
Waterfront · Islamorada Village
Direct Gulf access with deep-water canal frontage. Private dock, tropical landscaping, and open-concept living at its finest.
Condo · Near The Reach
Updated interior with hurricane impact windows. Community pool, assigned parking, and just minutes from world-class snorkeling.
Bay Front · Indian Key
Rare bay-front opportunity on the quiet side of Islamorada. Expansive views, mature palms, and the sound of the bay at your doorstep.
"Carolyn made what could have been a stressful process feel effortless. Her knowledge of the Islamorada market is unmatched, and she negotiated terms we didn't even know were possible."
Michael R.
Homebuyer, Islamorada
"We sold our property in under three weeks. Carolyn's staging advice and marketing strategy were spot-on — she truly understands what buyers in the Keys are looking for."
Susan T.
Seller, The Pines
"As out-of-state investors, we needed someone who could be our eyes and ears on the ground. Carolyn provided detailed walkthroughs, honest assessments, and complete transparency throughout."
David L.
Investor, Northeast
Whether you're ready to make a move or just exploring what's possible in Islamorada, Carolyn is here to help you navigate the market with confidence.
Reach out to schedule a no-obligation consultation. Carolyn responds to every inquiry personally and is happy to discuss your goals, timeline, and options.
Office Address
81800 Overseas Hwy
Islamoreada, FL 33036
Phone
(305) 741-4866Office Hours
Monday – Saturday: 9 AM – 6 PM
Sunday: By appointment
Fill out the form below and Carolyn will get back to you within one business day.
Message Sent!
Thank you for reaching out. Carolyn will respond within one business day.
